Cant believe you left Steve young off that list, 230 passing tds, 33000 yards 3 SB's 40 rushing Tds 4000 rushing yards and a career 97 passer rating, he definitely needs to be up there. especially from a niners fan!

1) Montana (i cant see an argument for it, i really cant)
2/3) Peyton/Young depends on how peytons career ends up
4) Brady (3 rings and great stats)
5) Toss up, i cant put favre here, just too many errors in too many games. He has incredibly good numbers but also has the records for all the things a great player shouldnt. Ill throw Elway here.